He allowed INSPECTION OF DU RECORDS FOR MODI DEGREE DETAILS
New Delhi: Chief Information Commissioner R K Mathur has taken away Ministry of HRD from Information Commissioner Sridhar Acharyulu who had recently ordered Delhi University to make public records related to students of BA course of 1978, the year in which Prime Minister Narendra Modi had passed out.
Soon after reports of Acharyulu ordering disclosure of records pertaining to students passing out BA course in 1978 came in public domain, an order was issued for reallocation of work among the information commissioners.
"The revised reallocation of work will come into force with immediate effect. The deputy registrars concerned are directed to transfer all the pending case files (except in which notice(s) of hearing have already been issued) with them to the concerned registry as per the re-allocation of work under intimation to the Registrar," the order said.
THE SEQUENCE OF EVENTS
June 2016: An RTI application moved by a petitioner on the details of roll numbers and marks of PM Modi in both Delhi University (BA) and Gujarat University (MA). Sridhar issues noticesto both the universities to provide the same.
Later one Neeraj sought 1978 BA degree details of all candidates of Delhi University. Sridhar issues orders to the effect and also directs DU to facilitate inspection.
Two more cases on BA degree details of all candidates filed by RTI activists following this order. They (Mohd Irshad and Sanjay Singh) said their RTI applications and Indian Postal Orders (challans) were rejected and sought CIC intervention. Show-cause notices issued and Rs 25,000 penalty imposed on DU authorities.
On December 29, 2016, the Centre removed Delhi government from the subjects allocated to Madabhusi Sridhar. And on January 10, 2017 it removed the Ministry of HRD allocated to Sridhar. (Reshuffling of portfolios is done periodically).
It said the reallocation has been done "by the Chief Information Commissioner." The change came within 10 days of a previous order dated December 29, 2016 in which Acharyulu had retained the Ministry as part of his job portfolio.
The CIC is the administrative head of the Central Information Commission having powers to allocate or reallocate work. The change comes within two days of Acharyulu's order directing inspection of 1978 records becoming public.
On January 8, it was reported that Acharyulu had directed the Delhi University to allow inspection of records of students who had passed BA course in 1978, the year in which Prime Minister Narendra Modi, according to the university, had also cleared the examination.
In his order, dated December 21, 2016, on the plea of one Neeraj, who had sought to know from the university the total number of students who had appeared for the BA examination in 1978, their names and those of their fathers, roll numbers and marks obtained, Acharyulu ordered the university to give details to the applicant.
Denying the information, the Central Public Information Officer of the university had said the information requested was "personal information of the students concerned, the disclosure of which has no relationship to any public activity or interest".
Acharyulu, however, said, "With regard to question whether disclosure of such identification related information causes invasion of privacy, or is that unwarranted invasion of privacy,
the PIO has not put forward any evidence or explained possibility to show that disclosure of degree related information infringes the privacy or causes unwarranted invasion of privacy".
"If the degree related information sought is about a celebrity or an ordinary man, the access to information has to be provided by the public authority.
The PIO did not come up with any basis for considering the degree related information of the students as third party information, except claiming so," he had said.
Observing that the CPIO should have applied her mind before denying information, Acharyulu said the Commission found neither merit nor legality in the contention of the university that the degree related information about students was third party information.