CEA Calls For E10 Petrol Option For Older Vehicles Amid E20 Debate

Update: 2026-08-17 13:12 IST

Chief Economic Adviser V Anantha Nageswaran

Chief Economic Adviser V Anantha Nageswaran has suggested bringing back E10 petrol for older two-wheelers as the debate over the country's E20 fuel policy continues.

Nageswaran and Department of Economic Affairs consultant Akash Poojari also urged for a comprehensive analysis on the impact of expanding ethanol blending beyond 20% in a column in The Indian Express. They added that policymakers should take into account the potential consequences on feed supplies, animal feed, agricultural land, and water resources before taking steps towards the use of greater blends like E27 and E30.

The authors believe that approximately 75 million to 80 million pre-BS-IV and carburettor-powered two-wheelers are still on the road in India.

They say that these vehicles have unique problems at higher ethanol blends. The reason behind was stated that the carburettor-based engines are not capable of adjusting the fuel-air mixture to compensate for the extra oxygen in ethanol, engine performance may be affected, resulting in a leaner mixture and higher running temperatures.

It's possible this sort of vehicles could later be retrofitted with ethanol-ready parts, but the process could take a long time if it has to be done for tens of millions of vehicles.

Nageswaran and Poojari therefore propose making E10 petrol available alongside E20 for the older fleet during the transition. They argue that this would give owners of older vehicles a lower-ethanol alternative while reducing the amount of ethanol required overall.

The CEA's argument goes beyond the immediate concerns of older vehicle owners. The authors have urged policymakers to examine the consequences of increasing ethanol blending beyond the existing 20% target.

India produces ethanol from several agricultural sources, including sugarcane, maize, rice and other grains. As demand for ethanol increases, these crops face competing demand from fuel producers and the food and livestock sectors.

Maize is particularly significant because it is also widely used as animal feed. Greater diversion of maize towards ethanol could affect its availability and prices for poultry and livestock producers unless agricultural production rises sufficiently.

The authors warn that moving towards blends such as E27 or E30 could intensify this competition between fuel and food.

The authors argue that the water footprint of ethanol production should not be assessed only by examining the water used inside distilleries. The water required to grow the crops used as ethanol feedstock also needs to be considered.

This is particularly relevant for water-intensive crops such as sugarcane. Increased demand for ethanol could influence cropping patterns and encourage farmers to allocate more land and water towards fuel-producing crops.

According to the authors, once agricultural land, water resources and industrial infrastructure become tied to fuel production, reversing those decisions could be difficult.

The government has defended E20 petrol, citing benefits such as reduced crude oil imports, foreign-exchange savings and increased demand for agricultural products.

It has also maintained that extensive testing has not found evidence of widespread engine damage from E20.

At present, E20 remains government policy, and there is no decision to move beyond the 20% blend. The government has also resisted calls for a nationwide choice between different petrol blends, citing the additional logistical and distribution challenges involved.

The proposal from Nageswaran and Poojari does not reject the broader benefits of ethanol blending. Instead, it calls for policymakers to weigh those benefits against the land, water, food and feed requirements associated with producing more ethanol.

For older vehicles, their immediate recommendation is to restore E10 as an alternative. For the wider ethanol programme, they advocate caution before India commits additional agricultural resources to higher blending targets.

Tags:    

Similar News