Sangh Parivar must persuade, not coerce, tribals
Sangh Parivar must persuade, not coerce, tribals
Ideological zeal and commitment help a political party grow in strength, so there is nothing wrong if its members indulge in activities to promote their cause. But every party must remember two principles. First, its ideology must have the potential to find resonance in the community that the party is targetting to win over—at least in a democratic polity. Second, activism must be done in a peaceful, persuasive manner, certainly not with the ‘my-way-or-the highway’ attitude.
Unfortunately for the Sangh Parivar, its ground troops are disdainful of the two principles. They have been accused of desecrating a religious site of the Santhal community in Odisha’s Keonjhar district over allegations of cow slaughter during a ritual last month. Sensing an opportunity to score brownie points, the Biju Janata Dal (BJD) supported the protest called by the tribal community. The state is ruled by the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), but the administration was forced to arrest five Bajrang Dal activists last week in connection with the incident. This has incensed the Vishwa Hindu Parishad, which sought the intervention of Chief Minister Mohan Charan Majhi.
This has put him in a tight spot, for he is not only himself a tribal but also hails from Keonjhar. The ruling party too is caught between the devil and the deep blue sea: on the one hand, it can ill-afford to abandon its foot soldiers to the slings and arrows of the long and painful legal process; on the other, it risks angering tribals whose electoral support it eagerly needs. In North India, the targets of saffron cowboys are quite clear—Muslims. As per the local police, last week’s arrests were made in connection with an incident on October 23 at Basantpura village when Bajrang Dal activists, armed with swords, iron rods and sticks, allegedly entered a sacred site, Jaher Than.
They claimed to be resisting cow slaughter as part of a ritual and disrupted the worship. In the melee between the tribal community members and the Bajrang Dal protesters, several people were injured on both sides. The accused persons have also been charged with misbehaviour with women and the draconian SC-ST (prevention of atrocities) Act.
The saffron establishment is in a quandary. To demonstrate its respect for the tribal community, Majhi criticises Leader of the Opposition Gandhi for allegedly skipping the recent tribute-paying ceremony to tribal freedom fighter Bhagwan Birsa Munda on his 151st birth anniversary. And right under his nose, a tribal place of worship is allegedly desecrated. The way out for the Sangh Parivar is simple: be mindful of the two principles mentioned earlier. An ideology cannot be imposed on a community; it must be made acceptable through dialogue and persuasion.
The tribals of Odisha have their own religious traditions, cultural practices, and social institutions, which deserve respect even when they do not conform to the Sangh Parivar’s understanding of Hinduism. Any attempt to browbeat them into accepting a particular interpretation of their faith is bound to be counterproductive. Worse, it will alienate precisely those people whose support the BJP and its ideological parent seek to cultivate. The Sangh Parivar must also understand that vigilantism, intimidation, and violence are not instruments of ideological propagation. Winning hearts and minds require patience and persuasion.