India Rejects UN racial Discrimination Panel’s Remarks As ‘Politically Motivated, Highly Malicious’
India Rejects UN racial Discrimination Panel’s Remarks As ‘Politically Motivated, Highly Malicious’
India has strongly rejected observations made by the United Nations Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (CERD), describing references in the panel’s report as “politically motivated” and “highly malicious.”
The Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) said on Wednesday that it had taken note of the committee’s observations following India’s 11th periodic review under the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (ICERD), held in Geneva on August 11 and 12.
India has joined the review process with a constructive approach and reaffirmed its resolve to fight against racial discrimination, the ministry noted.
In the course of the review, India spoke about its constitutional protection, legal structure, pluralistic features and various measures taken to protect the disadvantaged groups.
The MEA noted the Indian team headed by Solicitor General Tushar Mehta has earlier objected to " sweeping" generalisations, allegations with no basis and claims which exceed the mandate of the committee.
The MEA clearly remarked, "While we will respond to the Committee's observations through the established procedure, the inter-Ministerial delegation, which was led by the Solicitor General of India, Shri Tushar Mehta, had already rejected the sweeping generalisations, unsubstantiated allegations, or tendency to exceed the Convention's mandate during the review meeting.
The ministry said it rejected all highly malicious references in the report with "all the contempt" it deserves, calling them "politically-motivated".
The answer was given in the wake of alleged “large-scale violations” reported by CERD against the Indigenous and Tribal Peoples, Scheduled Tribes, Scheduled Castes (including Dalits) and non-citizens, as well as ethnic and ethno-religious communities.
CERD is an independent body of experts that monitors the implementation of the ICERD, an international convention banning racial discrimination.
India's last review is for periodic reports submitted to CERD in 2023. The discussions were based on the administration of the convention in India and the progress of the marginalised communities and measures to overcome prejudice and intolerance, according to the Permanent Mission of India in Geneva.
"The Indian delegation highlighted our pluralism; diversity; scale and complexity; constitutional and legal framework and safeguards; affirmative actions, democratic accountability; judicial remedies; targeted public policy; and sustained socio-economic development, as we continue our journey towards ensuring equality, dignity and opportunity for all Indians," the official statement noted.
The Indian contingent highlighted the diversity and pluralism of the nation, the constitutional and legal safeguards, affirmative action policies, democratic accountability, judicial remedies and targeted welfare programmes.
India, too, had been involved in the development of the ICERD in the 1960s, when developing countries challenged colonialism, apartheid and racial discrimination.