Hyderabad’s hour: Reform legal education now

In Short

Judges are overworked. Many trial courts carry huge dockets, and some vacancies stay unfilled for long periods. Training adds to the burden, so it must be short, practical and well timed. Reform also costs money. Better faculty, clinics and academies need funds. The judiciary can lead, but it cannot pay for all of them alone. The judiciary must respect its own limits. Regulating the legal profession is the job of the BCI and Parliament.

Hyderabad’s hour: Reform legal education now
X

Hyderabad’s hour: Reform legal education now

Font size
FOLLOW ON Google News

Hyderabad will be hosting the first annual international conference on legal education, organised by the Commonwealth Legal Education Association (CLEA), on November 21 and 22. The Chief Justice of India, Chief Justices of various High Courts, senior judges and global delegates are expected to attend the conference.

They should not treat it as a ceremony. The case for reform is already on public record.

The factory that makes lawyers

India has about 2,000 law colleges. They produce roughly 80,000 to one lakh graduates a year. The criticism is that many of these colleges exist not to educate but to extract. The Bar Council of India (BCI) is criticised for acting less as a regulator and more as a gatekeeper that profits from access. That is the critic’s charge, and the BCI has its own account. But the charge is serious and deserves an answer.

The cost of weak training falls on the poor. As per the India Justice Report 2025, prisons hold over 5.06 lakh people against a capacity of 4.36 lakh, which is 131 per cent occupancy. About 76 per cent of inmates are undertrials. In Delhi, the share is 91 per cent.

Poor accused persons often have poor lawyers. A lawyer who cannot draft a sharp bail plea or test a police remand cannot protect a client. Bad legal education is not just an academic problem. It decides who walks free.

The bench has its own lessons to learn

It is easy to blame only law colleges. But the bench also needs schooling, and recent reports say so.

Look at two recent incidents. They speak of errors by the Chhattisgarh High Court on the Indian Penal Code. They also cite about 500 defective magistrate orders in Telangana that were set aside by Justice J Sreenivas Rao of the Telangana High Court. In another instance, a Supreme Court bench of Justices J B Pardiwala and K Vinod Chandran on 14 October called the state of a High Court’s handling of a murder appeal “pathetic.”

The Telangana High Court order said a sessions court had dismissed an appeal because the appellant was absent. The Supreme Court had already said many times that this is wrong, and the High Court had to say it again in 2026.

When the same basic error keeps returning, the likely cause is training, not bad faith.

Seven things to do on a war footing

War footing means deadlines, not speeches. The higher judiciary can act on most of this without waiting for the Parliament.

The first step is to audit law colleges. The Supreme Court and the High Courts should press the BCI to publish inspection reports, affiliation decisions and renewal records for every law college, and to say who inspected each college and what they found. Sunlight is the cheapest cure for a racket.

The second step is to close colleges that fail. A college that cannot show real faculty, a real library and real moot courts should lose recognition, and its students should be moved to better institutions at no extra cost.

The third step is to teach practice, not just theory. Every law student should spend time in a trial court, a legal aid clinic, and a police station or prison. They should learn to draft a bail plea, read a charge sheet and cross-examine a witness. Practical skills should count for as many marks as memory.

The fourth step is to make legal aid training serious. Legal aid lawyers handle the poorest clients, so they should get proper training, fair pay and supervision. An amicus appointed by a court should be someone who can do the job. The fifth step is to train judges early and often. Magistrates and district judges should have regular, compulsory refreshers on criminal procedure, bail, sentencing and appeals. High Courts should circulate short, plain notes on settled Supreme Court rules. One rule needs special attention: an appeal should not be dismissed because the appellant or his lawyer is absent.

The sixth step is to review orders for patterns. High Courts should track which kinds of errors are corrected most often on appeal. If one error keeps recurring, the response should be a targeted training module, not just another reversal.

The seventh step is to keep learning after enrolment. The BCI is reportedly moving towards a National Legal Academy for advocates, following a Supreme Court direction with training of about 10 days to two weeks. If the plan goes ahead, the idea is sound. Lawyers and judges alike should keep learning.

The honest counterarguments

Judges are overworked. Many trial courts carry huge dockets, and some vacancies stay unfilled for long periods. Training adds to the burden, so it must be short, practical and well timed.

Reform also costs money. Better faculty, clinics and academies need funds. The judiciary can lead, but it cannot pay for all of them alone.

The judiciary must respect its own limits. Regulating the legal profession is the job of the BCI and Parliament. Courts can direct, monitor and nudge, but they should not take over that task.

Judicial independence is not at stake here. Training a judge in procedure does not tell her how to decide a case. It only ensures she knows the rules she must apply.

The larger point

Legal luminaries raise several related worries. They concern how judges are chosen, what post-retirement posts may look like, and how little machinery exists to examine complaints against the higher judiciary. These are separate debates. But all of them turn on one idea. A court earns trust by being competent and fair, and by being seen to be both.

Legal education is the root of that trust. A weak classroom produces a weak bar, and a weak bar produces weak benches. The accused in an overcrowded jail pays for each of those failures.

The Hyderabad conference can do something rare. It can turn another round of speeches into a short, time-bound plan with named owners and public deadlines. The country does not lack diagnosis. It lacks follow-through. If the judges, regulators and educators in that room leave with only a joint statement, the conference will have failed. If they leave with a calendar of audits, curricula and training rollouts, it may be remembered as a turning point.

(The writer is with the Cholleti BlackRobe Chambers, Hyderabad, and his work spans economics, politics and law, bringing legal rigour and public-policy insight to contemporary debates)

Next Story
Share it