Supreme Court Dismisses ‘Aaya Ram, Gaya Ram, Phir Aaya Ram’ Case
In Short
The Supreme Court upheld the disqualification of Khairatabad MLA Danam Nagender, triggering a by-election and intensifying political focus on BRS-Congress defections in Telangana ahead of key elections.

Supreme Court of India
The Supreme Court’s ruling upholding the Telangana High Court’s decision to disqualify Khairatabad MLA Danam Nagender, who was elected on a BRS ticket and later moved to the Congress, not only paves the way for a fresh election but also comes as a major setback for those who crossed over from the BRS to the Congress.
A bench headed by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and comprising Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana said it found no reason to interfere with the Telangana High Court judgment. The bench observed that the High Court had correctly interpreted the law. Justice Bagchi, in a lighter vein, remarked, “Your case is ‘Aaya Ram, Gaya Ram, Phir Aaya Ram’?”
The verdict is likely to put pressure on Assembly Speaker Gaddam Prasad to take a decision on the fate of the nine other MLAs who left the BRS and joined the Congress. However, there is a difference between Nagender’s case and that of the other MLAs. Nagender had contested the Secunderabad Lok Sabha seat on a Congress ticket while still being a BRS MLA, which became a key factor in the court’s decision.
In the case of the other nine MLAs, no such evidence is presently available in the public domain. Sources say that if the BRS pursues the matter against Kadiyam Srihari, there could also be a case for his disqualification, as he is said to have been a signatory to the electoral form of his daughter, who contested from the Ghanpur Assembly constituency as a Congress candidate. This, however, would have to be examined on its own facts.
With elections already on the horizon, the verdict could push all political parties into a sort of mini-election mode. Apart from the GHMC polls, MLC elections to the Mahbubnagar-Rangareddy-Hyderabad and Warangal-Khammam-Nalgonda Graduates’ constituencies, as well as elections to three corporations, are also due.
The Khairatabad by-election will be a political test for all the major parties and will provide an opportunity to assess voter preferences in the constituency. The Congress has the advantage of being in power and could give the ticket to Danam Nagender, although P Vijaya Reddy, daughter of former Congress leader P Janardhan Reddy, is also in the race.
There is likely to be a tug-of-war within the BRS over the party ticket. It is learnt that former minister T Srinivas Yadav wants the ticket to be given to his son, while former MLA P Vishnuvardhan Reddy could also stake his claim. He had represented the Jubilee Hills constituency in the past.
The BJP may decide to field Chintala Ramachandra Reddy, the former MLA from Khairatabad. Though he is a known face in the constituency, the contest is likely to be closely watched.
If the present political situation in the State is any indication, the Congress will seek to capitalise on its recent electoral gains. The party had won the Jubilee Hills and Secunderabad Cantonment by-elections and has also announced Indiramma housing schemes and other welfare measures for poorer sections of society.
It remains to be seen how the BRS campaign will work with voters. The by-election will provide an opportunity to gauge the ground situation and voter perceptions of the major political parties.

