EC's appointment row: 5-judge bench can examine plea to recall split verdict

In Short

The Supreme Court indicated that a five-judge Constitution Bench can take up a plea seeking recall of an earlier split verdict on the 2023 election commissioners law, declining a separate hearing after Prashant Bhushan raised conflict-of-interest concerns.

5-judge bench can examine plea to recall split verdict
X

5-judge bench can examine plea to recall split verdict

Font size
FOLLOW ON Google News

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Friday indicated that a five-judge Constitution Bench hearing challenges to the 2023 law governing the appointment of election commissioners can also take up a plea seeking the recall of an earlier split verdict on whether the matter should be referred to a larger bench. Refusing to entertain a separate hearing, the court said both the recall application and challenges to the reference order could be considered by the Constitution Bench.

The issue was brought before a bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana. During the hearing, advocate Prashant Bhushan argued that the recall application should be placed before the original bench comprising Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma, which delivered a divided verdict on September 23.

Bhushan raised concerns over an alleged conflict of interest involving Justice Sharma and maintained that the application seeking withdrawal of the earlier decision should be heard by the same judges who had delivered it.

Purna Singh Yadav is an experienced journalist specializing in politics and general reporting. With over 3 years of writing expertise in political as well as general reporting. Purna has completed her post-graduation from Amity University with specialization in public relations and advertising. When she is not immersed in writing, she can be found spending time watching movies. With three years of experience as a frontline journalist, she has honed her craft in various genres, including entertainment, crime, and education. Purna's diverse family history and embrace of cultures as well as good communication skills have enriched her writing with unique perspectives.

Next Story
Share it