Live
- Vote judicially to decide PM to make India developed: Kishan
- ‘Anwesha’ offers quality education to ST and SC students
- Congress targeting nationalists to divide country: Dr Laxman
- BJP ‘charge sheet’ accuses BJD govt of rampant corruption
- Delhi court reserves orders on bail petition of Kavitha for May 6
- Konda Vishweshwar Reddy holds rally in Tandur
- Revanth fielding dummy candidates to benefit BJP: KTR
- KTR takes part in road show to boost cadre morale
- YS Jagan Credits YSR for Development in Pulivendula, rubbishes political allegations
- Empowering Patient Education: A Conversation with Naresh Ahuja, CEO of SMS Scientific Products Pvt Ltd
Inclusion of Law Minister in Judges' Appointment Impinges Judicial Freedom: Top Court
Highlights
The inclusion of Law Minister as an \"ex-officio member of NJAC\" for selection and appointment of judges in higher judiciary came under sharp criticism by the Supreme Court today with the majority view saying that his presence \"impinges upon\" the principles of \"independence of judiciary\".
.jpg)
The inclusion of Law Minister as an "ex-officio member of NJAC" for selection and appointment of judges in higher judiciary came under sharp criticism by the Supreme Court today with the majority view saying that his presence "impinges upon" the principles of "independence of judiciary".
Heading the bench that delivered the verdict, Justic J S Khehar said, "I have independently arrived at the conclusion, that clause (c) of Article 124A(1) is ultra vires the provisions of the Constitution, because of the inclusion of the Union Minister in charge of Law and Justice as an ex-officio Member of the NJAC."
He said that "Clause (c) of Article 124A(1), in my view, impinges upon the principles of 'independence of the judiciary', as well as, 'separation of powers'," Justice J S Khehar, who headed the five-judges constitutional bench."
Concurring with his view, Justice A K Goel observed that appointment of judges of the Supreme Court and appointment or transfer of judges of high courts, can certainly be influenced to a great extent by Law Minister and two nominated members of the six-member NJAC, which would affect the independence of judiciary.
"Appointment of judges of the Supreme Court and appointment/transfer of judges of the High Courts, can certainly be influenced to a great extent by the Law Minister and two nominated members, thereby affecting the independence of judiciary," he said.
"The plea that the Law Minister and the nominated members will provide feed back also does not provide any justification for their being members of the Commission and thereby participating in evaluation and suitability of a candidate for appointment as judge of the Supreme Court or High Courts and having power to overrule unanimous view of judges," he added.
Next Story
ADVERTISEMENT
