MyVoice: Views of our readers 22nd November 2026

In Short

The demand for multiple NEET-UG attempts and weightage to Class 12 board examination scores are genuine.

MyVoice: Views of our readers 22nd November 2026
X

MyVoice: Views of our readers 22nd November 2026

Font size
FOLLOW ON Google News

Welcome move by Team Nilekani

This is further to the news report ‘Multiple NEET attempts, weightage for Class 12 Marks’. The recommendations by several states to the Nandan Nilekani-led task force have reopened an important debate on the fairness and credibility of India’s medical admission system. These recommendations are most welcome as a single exam should never decide the fate of thousands of students who take the high-stakes NEET exam.

The demand for multiple NEET-UG attempts and weightage to Class 12 board examination scores are genuine. So far, there has been no weightage to the marks scored by a student in Class 12 and the ranks are decided entirely by one’s performance in the NEET exam. Moreover, NEET is held once in a year, unlike JEE Mains, which is held twice. Like JEE Mains, NEET also should have multiple attempts, and the entire exam should be conducted in an online mode so that paper leaks and other irregularities can be checked and avoided. This will need a lot of logistics, infrastructure and technical support, but careful planning and effective administration will be able to overcome the obstacles being faced in making NEET entirely online.

Examination reforms must also prioritise stringent security, accountability and the prevention of paper leaks. The exam reforms should succeed in tightening the grip on the exam mafia and in instilling confidence among students and parents.

Parimala G Tadas,Hyderabad-50

Not a credible alternative

Reducing a student’s entire future to a three-hour multiple-choice exam is not a measure of merit; it is a test of endurance (‘Multiple NEET attempts, weightage to Class 12 marks’). The proposal by various states to include Class 12 board marks and allow multiple attempts is a welcome step toward sanity. Our current system creates high-pressure that rewards rote memorization over genuine curiosity. However, simply adding board marks is not a magical cure. We must ask a deeper question: are our school boards truly standardized enough to be a fair benchmark across the country? Without harmonizing the evaluation standards of different boards, we risk trading one form of inequality for another. The government must ensure that the new framework reduces stress without diluting quality. True education reform requires us to value holistic growth over a single day’s performance. A nation that trusts its students with a fair, multi-dimensional evaluation will produce not just better doctors, but more balanced human beings.

K Chidanand Kumar, Bengaluru

UK, a safe haven for fugitives

The reported issue of former IPL Commissioner Lalit Modi, and his British citizenship raises serious questions about the scrutiny followed by the UK government while granting citizenship to foreign nationals. We often see fugitives from India and other countries settling in the UK, making their extradition a prolonged legal battle. Vijay Mallya is another example. Although India and the UK have an extradition treaty, legal hurdles delay the process. The UK government should strengthen its background verification by seeking relevant clearances from the applicant’s country of origin, particularly when serious criminal cases or warrants are pending there. Across Europe, concerns over illegal immigration and refugee policies have also raised questions about national security and the interests of local citizens.

Citizenship should be a privilege, not a haven from the law. Governments must balance humanitarian considerations with national security and ensure that fugitives do not exploit immigration policies to escape justice.

Nittala Siva Prasad, Hyderabad-62

Quad Summit-Not a complete success

The Quad leaders’ summit delivered a mix of concrete infrastructure and security mechanisms alongside familiar diplomatic rhetoric. While the Summit yielded tangible tools for maritime monitoring, digital connectivity and critical mineral supply chains, its direct impact on land-based South Asian security issues like cross border terrorism remains largely symbolic.

The Manila Summit moved beyond broad statements by operationalising specific infrastructure and surveillance frameworks that directly affect India and the wider Indian Ocean region. The Quad leaders’ joint press release unequivocally condemned terrorism and violent extremism in all forms, including cross border terrorism. However, because the Quad is not a military alliance and remains focused on maritime Indo-Pacific, it lacks a joint enforcement or sanctioning mechanism to deter state sponsored militancy in continental South Asia. Holding the Summit in Manila, the first in a non-Quad nation, was a calculated move to support the Philippines amid South China Sea tensions. For smaller South Asian nations like Sri Lanka, Bangladesh and the Maldives, the Quad’s focus remains heavily tilted toward great-power maritime competition rather than resolving their immediate sovereign debt or regional trade bottlenecks.

Quad nations expressed unity against unilateral maritime aggression, though smaller South Asian countries remain cautious about getting caught between Quad and Chinese interests. Bilateral trade tensions and unilateral US tariffs affecting Quad partners like India, stay undercut by unresolved tariffs disputes. Quad made some progress but not enough to usher in peace and stability to the world, as desired by Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

Govardhana Myneedu, Vijayawada

The Advent Wreath: A journey of hope, peace, joy and love

As we approach the beautiful season of Advent, we are invited to pause, reflect and prepare our hearts for the coming of Jesus Christ. This special season is rich in meaningful traditions and symbols that help us deepen our faith and experience the true spirit of Christmas.

One of the most cherished symbols of Advent is the Advent Wreath, with its four candles, each carrying a special significance. Have you ever wondered what these candles represent and why they are lit during the weeks leading up to Christmas?

Each candle symbolises one of the four beautiful gifts of the Christian faith: Hope, peace, joy and love. As we light them week after week, they remind us of God’s promises, His unfailing love and the light of Christ that shines into our world.

Let us explore the meaning behind these beautiful Advent symbols and discover how they can inspire us to prepare not only our homes, but also our hearts, to welcome Jesus this Christmas.

Jubel D’Cruz, Mumbai

Humanity in the age of Artificial Intelligence

The Cambridge Dictionary’s choice of “human” as its Word of the Year carries a deeper significance in an age increasingly shaped by artificial intelligence. Technology may transform industries, improve efficiency and solve complex problems, but technological advancement alone cannot define civilisation. Empathy, compassion, conscience, creativity and moral judgement give human existence its true meaning. Growing dependence on machines also raises concerns about employment, privacy, accountability and the erosion of personal relationships. Rather than resisting innovation, society must learn to govern it responsibly. On their part, governments should strengthen education, promote digital literacy and prepare workers for changing employment patterns through continuous reskilling. Technology companies must accept ethical responsibility for their creations. Machines may increasingly perform human tasks, but human dignity, judgement and responsibility must remain irreplaceable.

A Myilsami, Coimbatore-641402

Commercialisation of medical education plagues the nation

With a dismal ratio of 0.7 doctors per 1,000 citizens and a staggering 70 per cent shortage of specialists in rural regions, India’s healthcare is in a critical state. Yet 411 MBBS seats remain vacant nationwide due to systemic policy failures. Private institutions extort exorbitant annual fees that can go up to Rs 25 to 40 lakh pushing total graduation costs to over Rs two crore. This predatory pricing enabled by the government’s spineless regulation, forces brilliant underprivileged minds to forfeit earned seats. The administration sits idly wilfully ignoring the vital recommendations of the Dr Devi Shetty and Ranjit Roy Chaudhuri

committees. How can debt-laden graduates ever serve impoverished rural communities? By turning sacred healthcare into a playground for the elite the government has blood on its hands. It must shatter this corrupt cartel immediately and restore justice to deserving students.

Dr Vijaykumar H K, Raichur-584170

Political left, economic right

Can India become economically prosperous without leaving large sections of its population behind? India’s ambition to emerge as a leading global economy is reflected in its growing markets, expanding enterprises, technological capabilities and entrepreneurial achievements. Does economic growth automatically translate into better opportunities for everyone?

We need wealth creation, competitive businesses, private investment and entrepreneurial freedom. Equally, we need quality employment, fair opportunities, stronger small businesses, financial inclusion, accessible education and healthcare, and responsible use of technology. This brings us to an interesting proposition-Political left, economic right. Can we pursue market-oriented economic policies while remaining committed to social justice and inclusive development? The role of corporate governance and the responsibility of Boards is ensuring that wealth creation goes hand in hand with wider social opportunities. Hence, corporate responsibility must extend beyond CSR expenditure and become an integral part of business strategy and decision-making. The responsible institutions determine how widely the opportunities arising from that wealth are shared.

C K Subramaniam, Navi Mumbai-400705

Restoration of Statehood is the most viable solution

Three months of lull established by security forces in Jammu and Kashmir was rattled by back-to-back incidents of violence recently. On November 11, a terror attack on a checkpoint manned by Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) personnel in Kulgam left three jawans injured. On November 16, a local, whom the police suspected of having joined the terror ranks a few days ago, was killed after six days of a siege-like anti-terror operation in residential areas of Kulgam. In Kishtwar, two Special Police Officers (SPOs) of the J&K Police were found dead with bullet wounds, a day after they were reported missing in a forest range on November 11. The police and the Army, however, remain tight-lipped about the circumstances around the killing of these SPOs. There are conflicting reports on the circumstances that led to their deaths.According to the police, local recruits have come down to single digit or fewer than 10 in Kashmir.

That said, the decline in terrorist incidents and the silence of the streets should not be mistaken for peace. The current situation demands a political reach-out by the Centre to all the stakeholders of J&K. It must begin with the much-promised restoration of Statehood, which will give the voters a sense that their mass participation in the 2024 Assembly elections allowed their elected leaders to hold institutions accountable, and they were able to work freely to protect the interests of the region. Fighting terrorism is a continuous exercise, and even a brief lowering of the guard can prove costly. That the attackers could fire on a checkpoint, injure three personnel and then melt away through a marshy patch of trees and bushes suggests a thorough familiarity with the terrain. Such familiarity is rarely acquired without assistance, and it points once again to the local support, however limited, in the area.

It is also impossible to ignore the wider context. Pakistan has long been unsettled by every successful tourist season in the Valley, and the early snowfall has already filled Gulmarg, Pahalgam, Sonmarg and other destinations with visitors. Diwali and other festive celebrations, including those at Lal Chowk, have passed in a spirit of normalcy that is plainly unwelcome to the handlers across the border. Each time the Valley looks peaceful and prosperous, instructions are passed, and violence follows. This time the targets were security personnel, a tactic designed to spread fear among civilians, and tourists in particular, by suggesting that nobody is safe.

Yash Pal Ralhan, Jalandhar-144001

Restore deleted voter names legally

The Election Commission of India (ECI) submitted to the Supreme Court that deleted voters can use Form 6 for restoration, without facing prosecution on that ground. This kind of voter registration raises serious questions about legality, fairness, and accountability. Asking an 80-year-old deleted voter to submit Form 6 as if he or she were a first-time voter, effectively declaring that has never been registered or voted before, is not only illegal, but also unreasonable. Since there is no appellate forum above the Supreme Court, the President of India, as the constitutional head of the Republic, needs to consider a suo motu intervention and instruct the Chief Election Commissioner to restore the names of all eligible voters who were wrongly deleted, using the records and details already available with them, which is a legal process.

Dr O Prasada Rao, Hyderabad

The Hans India
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

The Hans India

Next Story
Share it