INDIA Bloc Seeks Permission To Question CEC Gyanesh Kumar In Supreme Court, Submits 48 Questions On SIR

In Short

The INDIA bloc has filed 48 questions with the Supreme Court in which it asks the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar and other Election Commission officials about the SIR process, the availability of voter data, access to ECINET and the EC's alleged dissent.

INDIA Bloc Seeks Permission To Question CEC Gyanesh Kumar In Supreme Court
X

INDIA Bloc Seeks Permission To Question CEC Gyanesh Kumar In Supreme Court

Font size
FOLLOW ON Google News

The INDIA bloc has asked the Supreme Court to put on record its concerns against the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar and other Election Commissioners about the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. The Opposition parties have tabled 48 questions to clarify the decision making process, difference in the poll panel and also voter data.

However, in the application, filed on Monday, the petitioners have contended that the Election Commission of India (ECI) had made statements in its reply to the current litigation without supporting documents or records.

They said that they needed to question the officials for answers to be backed by official documents; they noted that they were seeking information with the Election Commission.

The INDIA bloc are asking the court to seek answers from Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi and Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu, and others.

Questions centre around the process of decision making regarding the SIR, who was responsible for authorising specific actions and how the ECINET platform has been designed, modified and operated.

The petitioners sought to find out if the decisions were made by consensus by the Commission; when these were approved; and if any member had raised objections and dissent.

Opposition Wants Clarity About Nationwide SIR Decision

The Election Commission's Special Intensive Revision, which is to be conducted all over the country, is one of the main questions which has been brought up in the application.

The INDIA bloc is asking for information regarding the time and official process in which the decision was taken. It has also challenged an apparent contradiction in the responses given to two questions under the Right to Information (RTI) where the ECI had denied it had information regarding the decision for a nation-wide SIR, and in its 2025 order where it had stated that there is a need for SIRs.

The petitioners have sought the poll body to provide the name of the file numbers, dates of approval, whether the decisions were made during meetings or through circulation of files or electronically.

They've also requested information on the individual Commission members' approval of the orders.

Top Concerns About 'Differences' in Election Commission

The application also asks for information on possible differences between members of the Election Commission regarding issues concerning the SIR, ECINET, Form 6 and filing of appeals.

Petitioners have sought to know the number of times Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi made written objections, dissent, and/or reservations from February 19, 2025 to October 26, 2026.

They have tried to obtain the dates, file numbers and subjects of each of such instances.

The INDIA bloc has also sought assurance if there was a majority vote under Section 18(2) of the 2023 Act to take any decision relating to SIR. If it does, it desires to know what the decisions were and who was the dissenting member.

The issue has come into focus after reports of mishas on the Commission, leading to protests from the INDIA bloc parties and being part of their legal challenge.

The Opposition parties have questioned who has access to electoral roll data bases and how details regarding changes in voter records are collected.

They have asked for information on the officials or other agencies and organizations that are authorized to add, delete, modify, or restore voters' entries. There is also a question asking whether employees of private vendors or contractors have been given privileged or write access to the database.

The petitioners have requested to know the details of the Audit trails of ECINet, whether all changes made to entries of the electoral roll include details of the user account to which the change has been made, date of change, time of change etc., and whether the order passed by Electoral Registration Officer on the change made is reflected in the electoral roll.

Question Paper for Form 6 and West Bengal Appeals

The app also requests an explanation of the online Form 6 process, such as introducing the declaration requirement.

The INDIA bloc demands information regarding the number of applications that were rejected and those that have been kept pending due to applications that were not accompanied by the declaration and mapping information.

The petitioners have requested the information regarding the appeals filed against the order passed by judicial officers directing the names in the electoral rolls in relation to West Bengal.

They have sought to discover the number of such appeals, who authorised them and upon what basis cases were chosen for appeal.

Petitions to be heard at the Supreme Court on Tuesday

The application is part of the legal petition filed by the INDIA bloc against the Election Commission's SIR exercise. The Supreme Court has fixed Tuesday for the hearing of the petitions.

A three-judge bench presided over by Chief Justice Surya Kant at the last hearing on October 27 had extended 10 days to the petitioners to reply to a counter-affidavit filed by the ECI.

The poll body in its reply stated that all three big decisions taken on the SIR had been taken unanimously.

The INDIA bloc has said that the questions are being raised to confirm its claims and to get documents which cannot be accessed independently by the petitioners.

Always love to raise the unraised matter. In a world of worries, I am always ready to come over my comfort zone and taking the step ahead of spreading awareness.

Next Story
Share it