Who was Ashwani trying to shield ?
In a slow-moving justice delivery system, the fact that Law Minister Ashwani Kumar is still in the government is not surprising. In the sound and fury...
In a slow-moving justice delivery system, the fact that Law Minister Ashwani Kumar is still in the government is not surprising. In the sound and fury of the war between Attorney General G E Vahanvati and Additional Solicitor General Harin Rawal, the most important factor is not being given enough attention. In the ongoing drama around the coal scam, the most important question is what were the changes Ashwani Kumar wanted to make in Central Bureau of Investigation's draft of status report on coal mines allotment investigation that compelled him to call such illegal, unethical and unauthorised meeting? Who were the people he was trying to save? Were there any names of politicians or mines owners deleted from the draft report of the CBI?
In fact, the CBI's 26 April affidavit and even Rawal's letter to Vahanvati do not address the main issue. Rawal's explosion, through the letter, is limited to Vahnavati's conduct and double-standards. Why did Ashwani Kumar so brazenly summoned CBI officers and the law officers? What was his compulsion to flout the rules? Was he trying to help the vulnerable parties?
Was it only to shield Prime Minister Manmohan Singh as it's alleged, or was it also to shield some mines owners? The more important question is will the CBI quote those names which were taken out from the draft report if indeed they were? Was the CBI advised by the law minister to not include certain names even in a draft report?
The Supreme Court has taken a stand to first gather more facts and then proceed further. It has adopted the long route to justice by giving time to the people who are under the public scanner. Now, the ball is in the CBI's court. It will have to speak the truth and share what exactly transpired in that meeting. Was there any criminal conduct done in the meeting by any member present when some possible accused of coal-scam got favoured treatment?