Can't Blame Government If You Don't Vote, Observes Supreme Court
The candid admission of an activist seeking a blanket order to remove encroachments in the country and saying he has never cast his vote, did not go down well with the Supreme Court.
The candid admission of an activist seeking a blanket order to remove encroachments in the country and saying he has never cast his vote, did not go down well with the Supreme Court. Observing that the court cannot pass a sweeping order on encroachments in a matter involving all states, the bench headed by Chief Justice J S Khehar said, "One can't blame the government for everything. If a person does not cast his vote, then he has no right to question the government."
The bench, which also comprised Justices N V Ramana and D Y Chandrachud, said it was not possible for it to look into encroachments sitting in Delhi and asked the petitioner to approach different High Courts wherever he saw such encroachments on roads or pavements.
The observation came when Dhanesh Ieshdhan, appearing in person for Delhi-based NGO 'Voice of India', said the governments do not do anything to remove encroachments and kept on insisting for a blanket order to remove them from across the country.
The bench asked Mr Ieshdhan whether he has voted or not.
"To be honest, I have never voted in my life," Mr Ieshdhan said candidly.
This irked the bench which said, "If you have not voted, then you have no right to question or blame the government".
"We do not have so much power to order a clean sweep of encroachments. If we pass any order, then contempt cases and other petitions will pile up. It's not possible," the bench said after the petitioner kept on seeking a blanket order.
"If you do not move High Courts, we will feel that you are here for publicity," the bench said and noted in the order that an open-ended direction to remove encroachments will not serve any purpose.
It granted liberty to the NGO to seek remedy state-wise before the High Courts.